• Welcome to Orpington Astronomical Society.
 

News:

New version SMF 2.1.4 installed. You may need to clear cookies and login again...

Main Menu

Nikon Concentric Rings

Started by MarkS, Mar 12, 2023, 09:08:25

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

MarkS

If you want some light reading, I've written a couple of web pages documenting the Nikon Concentric Rings problems:
http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/NikonConcentricRings/nikon_lossy_compression.html
http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/NikonConcentricRings/nikon_hardcoded_correction.html

With the help of the astro-community sending me raw files I've been able to prove that Nikon has been doing this for at least the last 10 years! However, I don't expect this to go viral in the same way that my discovery and analysis of the Sony "star eater" went viral.

I don't recommend Nikon cameras for astrophotography.  In fact, I don't recommend Sony either and some Fujifilm models also have dodgy rings.  My advice for DSLR/Mirrorless astrophotography is to stick with Canon.

Mark

Carole

Wow Mark, that is some paper.  Well done. 

Have you communicated with Nikon about it? 

Carole

MarkS

Quote from: CaroleWow Mark, that is some paper.  Well done. 
Have you communicated with Nikon about it? 

Yes we'll contact Nikon but I'm not optimistic.  Sony has been applying a far worse colour shading correction for years and they don't care.  One Sony example I saw was a daylight wedding image from wedding photographer who was definitely not amused by concentric coloured polygons in his image!

Mark

Carole

Yet Canon does not apply any of this.  Long time since l used a DSLR DS images.  But l only ever used Canon as you advised me in the first place. 

Carole