• Welcome to Orpington Astronomical Society.
 

News:

New version SMF 2.1.4 installed. You may need to clear cookies and login again...

Main Menu

Comet C/2022 E3 (ZTF) on 18th and 20th Jan 2023

Started by MarkS, Jan 20, 2023, 08:52:03

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

MarkS

Here are a couple of single exposures (60sec at ISO 1600) taken with an unmodified Canon EOS R on a Tak Epsilon 180ED.

18th Jan at 3:40 GMT:

http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/2023/C2022_E3_ZTF_20230118.jpg

20th Jan at 4:40GMT:

http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/2023/C2022_E3_ZTF_20230120.jpg

I took over 60 exposures on each occasion so I should be able to produce better versions once I get round to doing the whole comet stacking mularky.  The main problem for stacking is the ion tail which changes quite rapidly.

It's well worth looking at Michael Jaeger's recent animation:
https://spaceweathergallery2.com/indiv_upload.php?upload_id=191664

Mark


Carole

Great work Mark.  Is the anomation showing where the Solar wind split the tail which I heard about on the OAS Whatsapp Group?

If you're going to re-stack, should I wait for new versions before presenting at the meeting?

Carole


MarkS

I don't know anything about a tail split but Michael Jaeger's animation clearly shows a big puff of gas streaming down the ion tail.  That's quite normal because gas rarely jets out at a constant rate. The animation also perfectly illustrates the problem with comet stacking.  If those frames are integrated together we end up with a long featureless time-blurred tail.

So I'm not yet sure what I'll do.

Dave A

Remember- we are the Universe and the Universe is us

MarkS

Quote from: DaveAllenGreat animation Mark

Yes, I wish it were my animation!  Here's an even better one taken with big aperture, fast optics and New Mexico pristine skies:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DilnEio971o&feature=youtu.be

Not that I'm jealous, of course  ;)


garrick

Really nice image. Stars and comet look great.

GW

Roberto


Carole

Bit confused Mark from the presentation of members images perspective.

You say you took a single 60sec shot on both, then later you say I took over 60 exposures on each occasion.
Please can you clarify.

Also aside from this, it is reported that this coment has a rare antetail, it is starting to become evident in your second image Mark. 

Carole

MarkS

Quote from: CaroleYou say you took a single 60sec shot on both, then later you say I took over 60 exposures on each occasion.
Please can you clarify.

Also aside from this, it is reported that this coment has a rare antetail, it is starting to become evident in your second image Mark. 

I took more than 60 exposures on both nights but I haven't (yet) stacked them.  So I posted a single 60sec exposures from each night.  Yes, the anti-tail is visible (just).  It is much more visible in Roberto's excellent image and also in Duncan's image (if he hadn't cropped it off!)

Mark

MarkS

Finally I obtained a result I'm pleased with from stacking those 60 one-minute subs:


http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/2023/C2022_E3_ZTF_20230120_60subs.jpg

Mark

The Thing

Very nice Mark. I've not seen the dust tails so clearly on other shots.

Roberto

Excellent Mark!  The anti-tail is something to behold in this one.