Orpington Astronomical Society

Astronomy => Technical => Topic started by: MarkS on Mar 12, 2023, 09:08:25

Title: Nikon Concentric Rings
Post by: MarkS on Mar 12, 2023, 09:08:25
If you want some light reading, I've written a couple of web pages documenting the Nikon Concentric Rings problems:
http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/NikonConcentricRings/nikon_lossy_compression.html
http://www.markshelley.co.uk/Astronomy/NikonConcentricRings/nikon_hardcoded_correction.html

With the help of the astro-community sending me raw files I've been able to prove that Nikon has been doing this for at least the last 10 years! However, I don't expect this to go viral in the same way that my discovery and analysis of the Sony "star eater" went viral.

I don't recommend Nikon cameras for astrophotography.  In fact, I don't recommend Sony either and some Fujifilm models also have dodgy rings.  My advice for DSLR/Mirrorless astrophotography is to stick with Canon.

Mark
Title: Re: Nikon Concentric Rings
Post by: Carole on Mar 12, 2023, 09:54:02
Wow Mark, that is some paper.  Well done. 

Have you communicated with Nikon about it? 

Carole
Title: Re: Nikon Concentric Rings
Post by: MarkS on Mar 12, 2023, 10:51:13
Quote from: CaroleWow Mark, that is some paper.  Well done. 
Have you communicated with Nikon about it? 

Yes we'll contact Nikon but I'm not optimistic.  Sony has been applying a far worse colour shading correction for years and they don't care.  One Sony example I saw was a daylight wedding image from wedding photographer who was definitely not amused by concentric coloured polygons in his image!

Mark
Title: Re: Nikon Concentric Rings
Post by: Carole on Mar 12, 2023, 21:33:13
Yet Canon does not apply any of this.  Long time since l used a DSLR DS images.  But l only ever used Canon as you advised me in the first place. 

Carole